Is the idea of "Victim Blaming" biblical?
There is clarity & a balance to discuss. We are to take a cautions approach to the issue, and call believers to exercising wisdom and precaution in this fallen world; by being someone who exercises spiritual & practical prudence, taking heed to avoiding sin and leading others into temptation.
We need to do all we can to live in purity, pursue what's good, benefits others good, encourages, avoids sin and causing others to sin. The "victim blaming" term has been used in sinful twisted ways by the unsaved in the world...to allow them to sin and not care about others (so that no blame is equally given to the one who becomes a victim, in some cases). Using common sense and biblical sense we can see that man is sinful, every thought and his heart is very wicked, and he goes about in his sin seeking sinful things (to do as they want to) not caring it is at others expense.
Be wise, dont think fleshly sinfully minded, nor live the way the unsaved do. Live wisely. Don't put yourself in situations where you might become a easy victim, [eg. Dress modestly, dont be in private places alone with someone sexually interested in you (or might be), nor be alone with a man, dont go places alone (for safety), dont drink or do drugs, dont go to parties organized by unsaved people, nor go to bars and places women can be drugged, etc].
If you are doing everything right, as best you can, and still fall victim to some evil person... then you are a victim of x crime committed against you. In cases above youre still a victim of sinful people committing crimes, its just that it may have been prevented if you had wisely took precautions, used common sense, and were situationally aware. You may have played a part in allowing or luring their evil temptation to sin. And thus you have to admit that you were part of the problem which led to the crime.
Think of it this way, if you were married and you both had a big argument fight, who started it? who was in the wrong? And, it escalated cuz you threw fuel in it that fanned the flames. If he said something unkind, mean, rude, accusitory, demanding, assumed, judged you incorrectly about something, or brought up the forgiven past with some snide comment, then your response should be godly (having the godly mindset to think, speak, act, respond right). But unsaved dont care they do what they want, and think theres no consequences. But maybe believers who arent mature yet can make similar mistakes, but we care to correct. In this situation, if equally yoked, we are to have a forgiving, patient, gracious and loving mindframe so what outflow is proper responses and behavior that doesnt add fuel to fan the flames, but to extinguish it. Dont react wrongly in sin by emotions and hurt feelings, instead respond in truth, and dont behave like every argument is a hill to die on, some things not important like the trash, dishes, etc are not escalation worthy. And we don't need our feelings hurt over every little thing. What he says does tell us some things hes thinking, even if hes got it wrong. You could calmly say, "Oh, I wasnt aware the xyz was still an issue. I thought we discussed that in the past, forgave and left it there dead and forgotten, like God did with our sins. If you would like to talk about it later, before bed, to clear things up, Im happy to sit and do so. I love you, and love is patient, gracious, forgiving and kind. If the matter wasnt resolved we should pursue that so theres no sinful bitterness or resentment lingering." Or "Oh, is there still unresolved problem with/in (xyz area)? Lets sit & talk about it, striving to resolve it, once youre calmer". Or something like that. Apologizing when wring & self correcting. Communicating and pursuing holiness are important in marriage. You cant not address it. You want to pursue holiness, become g more like Christ, desire godly counsrl, repent, pray and etc.
But if both are at fault cuz both did something sinful connected to the issue, causing a problem, then both are to blame, cuz both sinned. And it needs addressing and correcting.
Christisns wouldn't dress/walk around in public like a prostitute and not expect to be treated as one. And wouldn't walk naked, in underwear, or lingere with the curtains or windows open, cuz you don't want an evil person to stare/watch you, try to take pics, or break in and assault you. Youre wise enough to protect yourself by keeping the curtians closed. The same thing is true in the other situations noted earlier. And you'd even add a layer of protection by having someone with you (in public outings) [as often as possible] to deter criminal activities (evil minded men, picking off solo prey). And maybe add bringing a dog that will protect you both too, in case of multiple criminals out looking for victims.
Christians know we live in a evil fallen world, and that most people are not just sinners but children of Satan, roaming around seeking to prey on, steal, destroy and kill. So women have to be wise, biblically minded, using critical thinking, common sense, be situationally aware, and not go places alone. Getting godly counsel and living holy as best as possible, without letting our guard down [even at home, as theres not just young folk & teams of robbers wanting in and to do evil, but even neighbors are lurking looking for evil opportunities].
Biblical Wisdom and Prudence: Scripture also commands us to be wise and discerning in a fallen world (Proverbs 22:3; Matthew 10:16). This is not victim blaming—it’s recognizing that sin exists and taking steps to avoid unnecessary danger.
Examples include:
Dressing modestly to avoid provoking lust (1 Timothy 2:9-10).
Avoiding risky situations (being alone in unsafe places, where alcohol & drugs are likely to be, etc.).
Practicing situational awareness and protection (locks, companions, dogs, etc.).
Being wise is about prudence, not moral culpability. A victim may have been careful, yet still fall prey to evil.
2. Scriptural Foundations for Prudence
Galatians 5:13: Our freedom must be used responsibly, serving others in love—not as an excuse to indulge the flesh.
Applied to safety: freedom in Christ does not mean carelessness.
Romans 14:13 & 1 Corinthians 8:9: Don’t put a stumbling block in another’s way. Practically, this encourages us to avoid creating situations where we or others might be vulnerable.
Matthew 18:6: Highlights the seriousness of causing someone to sin. Protecting oneself and others from exposure to sin or danger is part of loving your neighbor.
While people are accountable for their own sin (James 1:14-15, Exodus 22:16-17; Matthew 18:6), we can sin or encourage sin, by doing something that lures an evil person to us, seeing an easy target.
Avoiding actions that could lead others to sin is part of loving your neighbor and being obedient to God, not blaming victims.
Believers should set boundaries and exercise caution, both to protect themselves and to avoid causing others to sin.
Reinforces that evil is external; responsibility lies with the perpetrator(s), while prudence reduces the opportunity for sin.
1. Key Principle: Don’t Cause Others to Sin
Several passages explicitly teach that believers must avoid putting others in situations where they might be tempted or stumble:
Romans 14:13: “Therefore let us not pass judgment on one another any longer, but rather decide never to put a stumbling block or hindrance in the way of a brother.”
1 Corinthians 8:9: “…take care that this right of yours does not somehow become a stumbling block to the weak.”
Matthew 18:6: “But whoever causes one of these little ones who believe in me to sin, it would be better for him to have a great millstone fastened around his neck and be drowned in the depth of the sea.”
Application: These verses emphasize responsibility for how our actions affect others. They’re not about blaming victims, but about avoiding creating situations that could tempt or harm others, particularly in moral or sexual matters.
2. Integrating Prudence With Not Causing Sin
This is where modesty, situational awareness, avoiding risky situations fit in.
Modesty & Clothing: Dressing in a way that avoids provoking lust is not sinful compliance—it’s loving others by not creating unnecessary temptation (1 Timothy 2:9-10) for sexual crimes to take place against you.
Avoiding Risky Situations: Not going alone into private spaces with potential predators, avoiding unsaved parties or going to bars, and maintaining situational awareness are ways of protecting both oneself and others from sin and harm.
Practical Protections: Companions, dogs, locks, and other safety measures are additional layers of protection, reflecting prudence and love for self and neighbor.
These measure reflect wisdom in a fallen, sin-saturated world. The goal is to prevent situations where evil could be enacted or tempt others to sin.
Avoiding actions that could lead others to sin is part of loving your neighbor and being obedient to God, not blaming victims.
Believers should set boundaries and exercise caution, both to protect themselves and to avoid causing others to sin.
Reinforces that evil is external; responsibility lies with the perpetrator(s), while prudence reduces the opportunity for sin.
1. Key Principle: Don’t Cause Others to Sin
Several passages explicitly teach that believers must avoid putting others in situations where they might be tempted or stumble:
Romans 14:13: “Therefore let us not pass judgment on one another any longer, but rather decide never to put a stumbling block or hindrance in the way of a brother.”
1 Corinthians 8:9: “…take care that this right of yours does not somehow become a stumbling block to the weak.”
Matthew 18:6: “But whoever causes one of these little ones who believe in me to sin, it would be better for him to have a great millstone fastened around his neck and be drowned in the depth of the sea.”
Application: These verses emphasize responsibility for how our actions affect others. They’re not about blaming victims, but about avoiding creating situations that could tempt or harm others, particularly in moral or sexual matters.
2. Integrating Prudence With Not Causing Sin
This is where modesty, situational awareness, avoiding risky situations fit in.
Modesty & Clothing: Dressing in a way that avoids provoking lust is not sinful compliance—it’s loving others by not creating unnecessary temptation (1 Timothy 2:9-10) for sexual crimes to take place against you.
Avoiding Risky Situations: Not going alone into private spaces with potential predators, avoiding unsaved parties or going to bars, and maintaining situational awareness are ways of protecting both oneself and others from sin and harm.
Practical Protections: Companions, dogs, locks, and other safety measures are additional layers of protection, reflecting prudence and love for self and neighbor.
These measure reflect wisdom in a fallen, sin-saturated world. The goal is to prevent situations where evil could be enacted or tempt others to sin.
1. Spousal Conflict Analogy
Scenario: Two spouses have a big argument. One may have started it, but both escalate it by sinful words or actions.
Counseling Insight: A biblical counselor doesn’t simply blame one person; they identify:
Who initiated sin (culpability)
How the conflict escalated (mutual contribution)
How future escalation can be prevented through wisdom, humility, and boundaries
Scriptural Basis:
Ephesians 4:26-27: “Be angry and do not sin; do not let the sun go down on your anger, and give no opportunity to the devil.” → Highlights responsibility to manage anger and avoid giving the enemy opportunities.
Galatians 5:13 / Romans 14:13: Freedom in Christ and avoiding causing a stumbling block applies here too—your words and actions can fuel conflict or protect peace.
Principle: Identifying the sin of both parties doesn’t negate the fact that one may have initiated wrongdoing—but it teaches prudence and personal responsibility to prevent future harm.
---
2. Parallel to Victim Protection
Now, map the same principle to the victim-prudence discussion:
Spousal Conflict Victim/Perpetrator Scenario
One spouse starts the fight (culpability) Perpetrator commits a sin (full responsibility)
Both may escalate it (mutual contribution) Victim may fail to exercise prudence (modesty, awareness), increasing risk—not sinning, just failing to prevent opportunity
Counselor points out both sides and how to avoid escalation Counselor teaches victim prudence and situational awareness while affirming no guilt for another’s sin
Goal: Reconciliation, holiness, and wisdom Goal: Protection, biblical boundaries, and healing
Key Insight:
Culpability is distinct from prudence.
Responsibility to avoid escalation or danger is part of living wisely and loving your neighbor, but it never shifts moral guilt to the victim, if the victim didnt do it intentionally or in rebellion to wise godly counsel based on biblical teaching for holy living.
Counseling focuses on growth, wisdom, and preventing sin/opportunities, whether in marriage or in a fallen world.
3. Practical Applications (Combined Framework)
1. Recognize Sin: Identify the true perpetrator (spouse or criminal) and assign moral responsibility.
2. Assess Mutual Contribution: Identify areas where escalation or risk could have been mitigated.
3. Apply Wisdom & Prudence: Teach practical steps to avoid future harm:
Spousal conflict → communication skills, boundaries, de-escalation
Fallen world → modesty, awareness, safety, godly counsel
4. Promote Holiness and Protection: Encourage actions that honor God, protect others from stumbling, and cultivate peace and safety.
Summary:
Both scenarios involve sin in a fallen world.
Both require distinguishing culpability from prudence.
Biblical counseling emphasizes:
1. The guilty party bears responsibility.
2. Everyone has a role in avoiding escalation or creating opportunity for sin.
3. Wisdom, prudence, and godly boundaries are part of obedience, love, and protection.
Part 2:
Looking at when both parties at fault, and cuculpability.
Scripture does assign blame to those who actively cause others to sin
1. Blame for Causing Others to Sin
Scripture is clear that those who tempt, mislead, or create stumbling blocks for others are held accountable:
Matthew 18:6 – “But whoever causes one of these little ones who believe in me to sin, it would be better for him to have a great millstone fastened around his neck and be drowned in the depth of the sea.”
Perpetrator is fully culpable.
Romans 14:13 – “Decide never to put a stumbling block or hindrance in the way of a brother.”
Believers are responsible for "not creating situations" where others may fall into sin, or pursue committing sin crimes against them.
1 Corinthians 8:9 – “Take care that this ...does not somehow become a stumbling block to the weak.”
Principle: God assigns responsibility to those whose actions cause others to sin, even indirectly.
2. Why This Is Different From Victim Blaming
The worldly unsaved people, feminists and flaunters of prudence and wise living will disregard biblical truth, prudence, wise living and holiness, and ignore any personal culpability, and only assign blame to the one who carries out the evil crime deed.
They'll wear hardly any clothing and walk around as if naked in private at home. They'll even go to places that allow people to be naked in public, and act as if man isnt sinful, has sinful and evil thoughts, then only blame the one who perpetrated the crime (that inevitably happened to her) by other sinful-evil people. Trying to absolve her if any culpability. And call you a victim blame if you point out her part in the crime happening.
Victim blaming occurs when we hold the victim morally responsible for the sin committed against them. Example: saying “She was raped because of her clothing or choices.” as if only she is to blame for the outcome; both played a role.
Causing someone else to sin refers to actively tempting, misleading, or creating opportunity for sin, e.g.:
A predator taking advantage of someone’s vulnerability intentionally. If the victim was ignorant/ oblivious, having never been taught, had no idea, was very naive, had no education from godly people or parents on matters that led to the crime, and lacked basic holy living & common sense awareness they're not to blame. She wasnt morally culpable in that case. But knows better now, after the fact.
Leading one into sin through careless or manipulative actions (1 Corinthians 8 example), is sin, and makes you morally culpable.
Key Distinction:
Victim may be unwise or imprudent → potential opportunity exists.
Moral guilt → resides only with the one who actively commits the sinful act, (thus includes victim if (she) purposely disregards prudence, or tempts another into sin).
3. Connecting to the Prudence Discussion
When Scripture warns against causing sin or being a stumbling block, it encourages prudence in our own actions:
Modesty, awareness, avoiding risky situations → protects others from sin temptation.
→ generally protects you from crimes committed against you.
However, if someone sins against you despite prudence, Scripture does not assign moral blame to you, as you were not being flippant about it, you were living holy, not disregarding or not caring in rebellion.
The perpetrator remains fully culpable, just as in Matthew 18:6.
4. Summary
Situation Scripture Responsibility / Culpability
Someone is led into sin by another’s manipulation, rebellion or indifference to holy living 1 Cor 8:9; Matt 18:6. The Person causing temptation is morally culpable.
Avoiding tempting others Romans 14:13 Believers are responsible for not causing others to stumble.
Believers view these things not as the sinful unsaved in the world does, but in truth and with accountability to God; they desire to live rightly. Where blame is appropriate, the person is counseled, & sin is addressed, so the victim can self correct, and not live unwisely nor sinfully anymore.
====Some Verses noted===
Galatians 5:13
"For you were called to freedom, brothers. Only do not use your freedom as an opportunity for the flesh, but through love serve one another."
Romans 14:13, which says:
"Therefore let us ... decide never to put a stumbling block or hindrance in the way of a brother."
1 Corinthians 8:9. It states:
"But take care .... not somehow become a stumbling block to the weak."
Matthew 18:6
"But whoever causes one ...who believe in me to sin, it would be better for him to have a great millstone fastened around his neck and to be drowned in the depth of the sea."
John 8:11, Jesus said, "Go, and sin no more".
